Skip to content

My research as a Computer Security student: Exploring whether the UK government have adequate provision to secure critical infrastructure from cyber attack

, My research as a Computer Security student: Exploring whether the UK government have adequate provision to secure critical infrastructure from cyber attack, CARDIFF MET BLOGS
, My research as a Computer Security student: Exploring whether the UK government have adequate provision to secure critical infrastructure from cyber attack, CARDIFF MET BLOGS

Every day we all rely upon Critical Infrastructure and its many different aspects to go about our daily lives, yet many of us rarely think about how secure these operations are and the implications that a cyber-attack would have on the delivery of these services.

In 2019 I embarked on my foundation year at Cardiff Met, it was here that I first started to explore the role of CI within society and the using my past experiences in the military I became specifically interested in understanding at what point a cyber-attack could cross the threshold allowing use of conventional military retaliation.  In year 2 of my Computer Security degree I continued exploring this idea but wanted to better understand if the government had sufficient measures in place to secure the countries CI from attack, I therefore completed my research proposal and in my final year embarked on my research project.

One of the first things I needed to understand was the market makeup of the British economy. The vast majority of CI was sold off to private corporations in the 1980s, thus transforming the economy into that of a market capitalist. Operators of Essential Services (OES) have worked under a private public partnership with the government, what this means essentially is that the government has little control over the daily operations of these services and their only form of intervention is through policy and regulation.

Therefore, I needed to understand if the UK government had strong enough regulation in place to be assured that CI was secure. During my research I found that the UK has little regulation and only states that within the Network Information Systems Regulation that an OES must have appropriate and proportionate technical and organisational measures in place. I found this lack of clarity and detail quite concerning.  The UK Gov provides a framework through the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) for an OES to measure its ability to protect itself, although the NCSC highlight that not every element of the framework would be appropriate for all CI sectors and leaves the onus on the supplier to pick and choose the areas of the framework that would suit them best.

In order to answer my research question, I devised a scenario in which a fake water company used the framework to secure its services from attack and after conducting a literature review where I looked at past attacks on CI, I determined whether my water company would have been protected from these same attacks.  I concluded that although OESs within the UK have the ability to protect themselves, they struggle to see past the financial burden of improving their security posture, and with the UK Gov having little control over the daily operations of its CI it was not possible to conclude that they did in fact have sufficient measures in place, this was backed up when in 2019 a parliamentary committee stated that UK CI was wide open to attack.

I thoroughly enjoyed researching this topic and hope that I will be able to follow up on this research in the years that come to ensure that the stability of CI within the UK is protected for generations to come.